Electronic timing control



March 20, 1945. c. E. SMITH I ELECTRONIC TIMING CONTROL Fild Feb. 18, 1943 jg'N ESSES:'

BY W ATTORNEY Patented Mar. 20, 1945 ELECTRONIC TIMING CONTROL Clyde E. Smith, Warren, Ohio, assignor to Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing Company, East Pittsburgh, Pa., a corporation of Pennsylvania Application February 18, 1943, Serial No. 476,309

11 Claims.

This invention relates to an electronic timing control and has particular relation to a system for supplying current from a source. to a load through electric discharge devices.

In resistance welding apparatus constructed in accordance with the teachings of the prior art, current is supplied to the welding transformer from an alternating-current source through a pair of inversely connected ignitrons which are controlled by an electronic timing system. Des'irable welds may be produced by controlling the ignitrons so that welding current i supplied in a. series of spaced impulses, each impulse enduring for a predetermined nmnber of half periods of the source with an interval of another predeperiod of the on-time interval at which the corresponding ignitron is rendered conductive is also adjustable to regulate the amount of heat developed in the material at the point of the weld.

In addition, it is advantageous to initiate each to that disclosed in the application of Finn H.

Gulliksen, Serial No. 271,951, filed May 5, 1939, issued as Patent 2,303,453 on December 1, 1942, and assigned to the Westinghouse Electric & Manufacturing Company. The prior system, al-

" though generally satisfactory in operation, in-

cludes a large number of electric discharge devices and their associated control circuits. Thus, the manufacture of the apparatus is expensive, and the number of points at which failure might occur is rather large. It follows that the cost of maintenance and repair is also high. l

from a source to a load which includes a simplified electronic control system whereby the current is supplied in spaced impulses, each impulse consisting of a predetermined number of half periods of the source with another predetermined number of half periods between successive impulses.

In accordance with the illustrated embodiment of my invention, a pair of capacitors are charged simultaneously from a direct current source through electronic valve means comprising a plurality of 'electric discharge devices. These devices include a high vacuum discharge device and another device of the arc-like type in series with each other and connected so that all the current for charging said capacitors passes therethrough. The control circuits of both the discharge devices are normally arranged to permit them to conduct current if the remainder of the circuit through the devices is complete. When the charge on the first of the capacitors attains a preselected magnitude, an impulse is impressed in thecontrol circuit of the high vacuum device to render it momentarily non-conductive and stop the flow of current. Thereafter, the potential onthe sec- 0nd capacitor is effective in the control circuit It is, accordingly, an object of my invention to provide new and inexpensive apparatus forsupthe potential is above a predetermined magnitude. A discharge circuit is provided for each capacitor, the discharge circuit for.said second capacitor including adjustable means to determine the rate of discharge of the second capacitor. When the potential on said second capacitor drops below the predetermined magnitude, both devices are again in condition to conduct current if the remainder of the circuit therethrough is complete. y

In addition to the high vacuum device and the device of the arc-like type, two other discharge devices of the arc-like type are provided, one for each capacitor. The first capacitor and its corresponding device are in series with each other but in parallel with the second capacitor and its corresponding series connected device. These parallel circuits are. of course, in series with the source of direct current the high vacuum device and the first device of the arc-like type. The discharge devices corresponding to the capacitors are normally maintained non-conductive but an impulse is impressed in the control circuits thereof tending to render them conductive at an instant in each period of the alternating source of welding current corresponding to the power factor angle of the load. Thus, whenever both the high vacuum device and the first device of the arc-like type are in condition to become conductive, they become conductive when the devices corresponding to the capacitors are rendered conductive at the instant in the next period corresponding to the power factor angle.

The firing circuits of the ignitrons are interconnected with the charging circuit for the first.

capacitor so that the ignitrons conduct current during the period in which the first capacitor is being charged and do not conduct while the first capacitor is not being charged. Thus, the ontime interval is determined by the rate of charge of the first capacitor and the off-time interval is determined by the rate of discharge of the second capacitor.

The novel features that I consider characteristic of my invention are set forth with particularity in the appended claims. The invention itself, however, both as to its organization and its method of operation, together with additional objects and advantages thereof will best be understood from the following description of a specific embodiment when read in connection with the accompanying drawing, in which the single figure is a diagrammatic view showing the specific embodiment of my invention.

In the apparatus as shown in the drawing, a pair. of welding electrodes 3 and 5 engage the material to be welded and are connected across the secondary 9 of a welding transformer l. The primary 13 of the welding transformer is supplied with power from a source of alternating-current potential 15 through a pair of inversely-connected ignitrons I! and l9. A pair of electric discharge valves 2| and 23, preferably thyratrons, which are hereinafter designated as firing valves, are arranged to control the ignition of the ignitrons I1 and I9. The ignition circuit for one of the ignitrons I1 extends from one side of the source l5 through a conductor 25, the anode 21 and cathode 29 of the firing valve 2|, the igniter 3| and cathode 33 of the ignitron ll and the pri- The ignition circuit of the side of the source 5 through the primary l3 of the welding transformer, 'a conductor 35, the

anode 31 and cathode 39 of the firing valve 23, the igniter 4| and cathode 43 of the ignitron Hi to the other-side of the source.

It is to be noted that the anode 27 of firing valve 2| is always of the same polarity as the anode 45 of the corresponding ignitron l1, and the anode 37 of firing valve 23 is of the same polarity as the anode 47 of ignitron I9. Thus, when a firing valve becomes conductive, ignition of the corresponding ignitron is effected. When an ignitron becomes conductive, the ignition circuit through the corresponding firing valve is shortcircuited by the discharge path through the ignitron, and the firing valve is rendered nonoonductive. The ignitron then becomes non-conductive at the end of the half-period of the source potential in which it was ignited.

The anodes 21 and 31 of the firing valves 2| and 23 are interconnected by a resistor '49. The

' grid 5| of one firing valve 2| is connected to the grid 53 of the other firing valve 23 in a circuit extending through a grid resistor 55, a secondary 51 of an auxiliary transformer 59, and another grid resistor 5|. The center tap 63 of the resistor 49 interconnecting the. anodes of the firing valves is connected through a pair of resistors 65 and 6! to the center tap 69 of the secondary 51 of the auxiliary transformer 59. The control circuit of the firing valve 2| may then be traced from its grid- 5| through the grid resistor 55 and a portion of the secondary 51 to the center tap 69 and thence through the resistors 61 and 55 to the center tap 63 of the resistor 49. The control circuit then continues from one end of the resistor 49 through the conductor 35, the cathode 33 and the igniter 3| of the ignitron I'I to the cathode 29 of the firing valve 2|. The control circuit of the other firing valve 23 may be traced from grid 53 through resistor 6|, a portion of secondary 5'1, resistors 61 and 65, a portion of resistor 49, conductor 25, cathode 43 and igniter 4| of ignitron |9 to the cathode 39 of the valve.

An alternating potential derived from the source |5 appears across the resistor 49 intercom necting the anodes of the firing valves. To eliminate the influence of this alternating potential from the controlcircuits of the valves 2| and 23, the primary H of the auxiliary transformer '59 is connected oppositely across the source 15. Thus the potential appearing across the secondary 51 of the auxiliary transformer 59 balances out the potential appearing across the resistor 49 interconnecting the anodes of the firing valves. A resistor '53 is connected across the primary of the welding transformer to absorb current surges and prevent backfire of the ignitrons.

It is apparent that the two resistors 55 and '61 are common to the control circuits of both firing valves 2| and 23. A direct-current biasing potential is impressed across the resistor 61 from an auxiliary source 15. This biasing potential is of such polarity and magnitude as to normally maintain the firing valves non-conductive.

I The other resistor 65 is connected in series with H another electric discharge valve 11 in an auxiliary circuit. The valve TI is preferably a thyratron and is designated hereinafter as the control valve. Another auxiliary transformer 19 is energized from the alternating-current source, and its secondary 8| is connected in circuit with control valve 11 and resistor 65 through a pair of rectifiers 83 and 85. The arrangement is such that a rectified alternating-current potential is thereby impressed in the auxiliary circuit. When the control valve 17 becomes conductive, current fiows through the resistor 65 in series therewith until the end of the half-period of the alternating-current potential, at which time the anodecathode potential of the control valve reaches zero and the valve ceases to conduct. The current flowing through the resistor 85 develops a potential thereacross of such polarity and magnitude as to counteract the biasing potential across the resistor 61 in the control circuits of the firing valves. The particular firing valve whose anode is positive at the instant the control valve becomes conductive, is then rendered conductive to effect ignition of the corresponding ignitron.

The control circuit for the control valve Tl may be traced from the grid 81 thereof through a grid resistor 89, a balancing bridge 9| including a resistor '93 and the secondary of an auxiliary transformer 91, and resistors '99, HH and IE3 to the negative terminal of a voltage divider H15. 'The'control circuit continues from an intermediondary I1I of the transformer III.

"complete.

control valve 11 is normally of such polarity and magnitude as to make the grid 81 highly negative with respect to the cathode I I5. a

A push-button switch I21 is arranged to connect the positive terminal of the divider I to the anode I29 of an electric discharge device I3I of the high-vacuum type. The cathode I 33 of the device I3I is connected to the anode I35 of a second electric discharge device I31 ofthe arc-like type, preferably a thyratron. The cathode I39 of the second device I31 is connected to a negative point on the divider through three paths. The first of these paths may be traced from the cathode I39 of the second device I31 through the anode MI and cathode I43 of a third electric discharge device I45 of the arc-like type, a rectifier 441, a potentiometer I49, and a capacitor I5I to the negative terminal of the divider I05. second path may be traced from the cathode I39 The of the second device through a second capacitor I53, the anode I and cathode I51 of a -third discharge device I59 of the arc-like type, and a resistor I6I to the negative terminal of the divider I05. A third path may be traced from the oathode I39 of the second device I3'I'through the anode I63 and cathode I65 of a fourth discharge device I61 of the arc-like type, and the primary I09 of the transformer II I to the intermediate tap I01 on the divider.

The grid I69 of the first discharge device I3l is connected to the cathode I33 through a sec- As current does not normally flow through the primary I09 of the transformer I I I, the first device I 3 I which is of the high-vacuum type, is in condition to conduct current if the remainder of the circuit is The control circuit of the second discharge device I31 extends from the grid I13 through a grid resistor I15 and the second capacitor I53 to the cathode I39. An adjustable resistor I11 is connected across the second capacitor I53 so that the capacitor is originally in a discharged condition.

Thus, there is a zero potential between the grid I13 and cathode I39 of the second discharge device I31, and, as this device is of the arc-like type, it is in condition to become conductive if the remainder of the circuit is complete.

The control circuit of the third discharge device I 45 extends from the grid I19 through a grid resistor I8I and resistors I83 and IOI to the cathode I 43. A direct-current potential is impressed across the resistor IOI through transformer I18, rectifier I and capacitor I82. This potential is of such polarity as to maintain the third device non-conductive However, a potential impulse is impressed across the second resistor I83 from the alternating-current source I5 through a phase shifting circuit I05 and an impulse transformer I81. The phase shifting circuit I85 is adjusted so that an impulse of such magnitude and polarity as to counteract the potential across resistor IOI occurs at an instant in each period of the source corresponding to the power factorangle of the load.:. When .the

impulse across resistor. I83 .is sufilcient to;overcome the biasing potential of the firstre'sistor IOI, the third device I45 is rendered conductive if the remainder of the circuit is complete. As

as to oppose the potential across resistor I0:I

following the closing of the push-button switch I21 causes the first, second, and third devices to become conductive. Current then flows from the divider I05 through the first, second, and third devices to charge the first capacitor I5I in series therewith at a rate determined by the setting of the potentiometer I49.

The control circuit of the fourth discharge device I59 extends from the grid I89 through a grid resistor I9I and resistors I83, IOI, I03 and I6I to the cathode I51. As the potential in the control circuit of the fourth device I59 is the same as that in the control circuit of the third device, they are rendered conductive simultaneously. Thus current also flows from the di- The control circuit of the fifth discharge device I61 extends from the grid I93 through a grid resistor I95, the first capacitor I5i to the negative terminal of the divider I05 and from the intermediate tap I01 through the primary I09 of the transformer III to the cathode I65. The potential impressed in this control circuit by the portion of the divider included therein tends to maintain the fifthdevice non-conductive. However, when the charge on the first capacitor I5I attains a preselected magnitude, the capacitor potential counteracts the biasing potential supplied from the divider I05 and renders the fifth device I61 conductive. Current then flows from the divider I05 through the first, second, and fifth devices and the primary I09 of the transformer III in series therewith. However, the duration of this current is quite short, for the flow thereof through the primary I09 impresses a potential impulse between the grid I69 and cathode I33 of the first device I3I through secondary I H to render it momentarily non-condum tive. As a result, the second, third, fourth and fifth devices also become non-conductive.

As scenes the potential impulse impressed in the control circuit of the first device I 3| through the secondary "I of the transformer III expires, the second, third, and fourth devices would again become conductive except for the fact that the second capacitor I53 is included in the control circuit of the second device I 31. capacitor I 53 is charged simultaneously with the first capacitor I5I, and the polarity thereof is such that the second device I31 is prevented from becoming conductive as long as the charge on the second capacitor I53 is above a predetermined magnitude. The predetermined magnitude depends upon the critical potential characteristic of the particular discharge device employed and the anode potential impressed thereon. With a Westinghouse KU627 thyratron and approximately 300 volts anode potential, the device hecomes conductive when the grid potential is more positive than 5 volts. It is apparent that the first, third, fourth, and fifth devices cannot become conductive until the second device is in condition to conduct current. The second capac- Then as The second is below the predetermined magnitude, the sec-- ond device I31 is conditioned to conduct .current and does so when the next counteracting impulse is impressed on resistor I83 in the control circuit of the third device I45.

A sixth discharge device I91 of the arc-like type is connected in series with a resistor I99 across the first capacitor I5I. The control circult, of the sixth device I91 extends from the grid 20I through another secondary 203 of the transformer I I I, a source of direct-current potential 295 such as a battery, and the resistor I99 to the cathode 201'. The potential source 205 maintains the sixth device I41 normally nonconductive. However, when the fifth device I61 becomes conductive, the current impulse impressed in the control circuit of the sixth device I91 through the transformer II I renders the latter conductive to discharge the first capacitor I5I.' The discharge of the first capacitor I5I is, of course, accomplished before the second device I31 is again in condition to become cn ductive.

As previously mentioned, the biasing potential supplied to the control circuit of the control valve 11 by the divider I and resistor IIlI is sufiicient to counteract the other potential across resistor 99 in the control circuit to maintain the grid 81 highly negative with respect to the cathode II5. A second phase shifting circuit 299 is energized from the source through the auxiliary transformer 91. The potential derived therefrom is rectified by the rectifier system 2H and impressed across the resistor 99. The direction of rectification is such that the potential appear- I ing across the resistor 99 has the Wave form of an inverted rectified alternating potential with 1 respect to the grid 81 of control valve 11. The

setting of the second phase shifting circuit 209, of course, determines the phase position of the positive peak of the inverted rectified alternating potential appearing across the resistor 99. This setting as will be explained hereinafter determines the instant in each half period at which the control valve 11 is rendered conductive.

When the first, second, and third devices are non-conductive, the potential impressed in the control circuit of control valve 11'by the divider I05 and resistor I9! is sufiiciently negative to prevent the peaks of the potential across resistor 99 from raising the resultant potential above the critical potential necessary to render the control valve conductive. When the first, second, and third devices become conductive, the upper terminal of the resistor I03 is effectively connected to the positive terminal of the divider I95 to render the grid 81 of the control valve 11 less negative. The magnitudes of the various potentials are such that the peaks of the resultant potential in the control circuit of the control valve 11 then rise above the critical potential of the control valve at an instant in each .half period of the source determined by the setting of the second phase shifting circuit 209. When the third device H15 again becomes non-conductive, the potential in the control circuit of the control valve 11 again becomeshighly negative to prevent the valve from becoming conductive.

The balance potentiometer 9| ordinarily does not impress a potential in the control circuit of control valve 11. However, if the starting characteristics of the ignitrons l1 and I9 should differ, an alternating component may be intro duced in the control circuitof the control valve by shifting the tap 210. Shifting the tap 2) ill causes the control valve to become conductive slightly earlier in one half-period than in the other and thustakes care of the difference in the starting characteristics of the ignitrons.

To initiate a welding operation, the push-button switch I21 is closed. When the next counteracting potential impulse is impressed in the control circuit of the third device I45, the first, sec-- ond, third, and fourth devices I3I, I31, I and I59 become conductive. The resultant potential in the control circuit of the control valve 11 rises above the critical potential of the valve at a predetermined instant in each half period of the source to render the valve conductive. The corresponding ignitron in each half period then conducts current to the welding transformer beginning at the predetermined instant in the half period. After a predetermined interval of time determined by potentiometer I49, the charge on the first capacitor I5I attains the preselected magnitude to render the fifth device I91 conductive. This time interval is the on-time interval.

When the fifth device becomes conductive, the first device I 3I is momentarily rendered nonconductive to halt the flow of current through the second, third, fourth and fifth devices. Thereafter, the second device I31 is prevented from again becoming conductive by the charge on the second capacitor I53. After a predetermined time interval, the charge on the second capacitor I53 is reduced to permit the second device I31 to conduct current. This time interval is the off-time interval for as long as the second device I31 remains non-conductive, the potential in the control circuit of the control valve 11 is such that the valve is maintained non-conductive.

While the second capacitor I53 is discharging through the adjustable resistor I11, the first capacitor I5I is completely discharged through the sixth device I91 which is rendered conductive through the transformer III in series with the fifth device I91. The sixth device I91, of course, becomes non-conductive when the first capacitor I5I is discharged to a potential just below the arc-drop of the device.

When the second device is again in condition to become conductive the next counteracting impulse in the control circuit of the third device again renders the first, second, third and fourth devices conductive.

From the foregoing, it is apparent that the ignitrons I1 and I9 are rendered conductive alternately at a predetermined instant in each half period of the source for a predetermined number of half periods .comprising the on-time interval. The ignitrons are then prevented from conducting current for a predetermined number of half periods comprising the oil-time interval. The on-time-and off-time intervals are then repeated as long as the push-button switch I21 remains closed.

Although I have illustrated and described the apparatus as specifically adapted for use as a seam welder, it is obvious that the timing system maybe used for other apparatus in which such control is desired.

Although I have shown and described a specific embodiment of my invention, I am fully aware that many modifications thereof are pos- .sible. My invention, therefore, is not to be restricted except insofar as :is necessitated by the prior art and the spirit of the appended claims.

I claim as my invention:

I 1, For use'in supplying current froma source toa load, the combination comprising valve means for controlling the flow of current to the load, a pair of capacitors, means for simultaneously charging said capacitors at predetermined rates, means responsive to a charge of a preselected magnitude on one of said capacitors 'for momentarily halting operation of said charging means, said charging means tending to become reoperative thereafter, means effective after said momentary halting to prevent reoperation of said charging means while the charge on the other capacitor is above a predetermined magnitude, means for discharging said other capacitor at a preselected rate after said momentary halting of said charging means, andmeans for controlling said valve means in accordance with whether said charging means is operative or inoperative.

2. For use in supplying current from a source to a load, the combination comprisin first valve means for controlling the flow of current to the load, a pair of capacitors, means including sec.- ond normally conductive electronic valve means for supplying current to simultaneously charge said capacitors at predetermined rates, means responsive to a charge of a preselected magnitude on one of said capacitors for rendering said second valve means momentarily non-conductive, meansresponsive to the charge on the other capacitor for thereafter preventing said second valve means from becoming conductive while the charge on the other capacitor is above a predetermined magnitude, means for discharging said other capacitor at a preselected rate after said second valve means are first rendered nonconductive, and means for controlling said first valve means in accordance with whether or not said second valve means are conductive.

3. In combination, a source of direct-current potential, a first electric discharge "device of the high vacuum type, a second electric discharge device of the arc-like type in series with said first device and said source, first control means for said first device arranged to permit -it to conduct current, second control means for'said second device arranged to permit it to conduct current, a pair of capacitors connected to be charged simultaneously at predetermined rates by current flowing from said source through said devices, means associated with said first control means and responsive to a charge of a preselected magnitude on one of said capacitors to render said first device momentarily non-conductive, means associated with said second control means for preventing said second device from becoming conductive while the charge on the other capacitor is above a predetermined magnitude, and means for discharging said second capacitor at a preselected rate after said first device is rendered non-conductive.

4. In combination, a source of direct-current potential, a first electric discharge device of the high-vacuum type, a second electric discharge device of the arc-like type in series with said first device and said source, a first control circuit for said first device normally arranged to permit it to conduct current, a second control circuit for said second device normally arranged to permit it to conduct current, means for initiating a flow of current from said source through said devices, a capacitor connected to be charged at a predetermined rate by the current flowing through said devices, means associated with said first control circuit and operable a predetermined time after initiation of said current flow to render said first device momentarily non-conductive, said capacitor being connected in said second control circuit in such manner as to prevent said second device from becoming conductive while the charge on said capacitor is above a preselected magnitude, and means for discharging said capacitor at a predetermined rate after said first device is rendered non-conductive.

5. In combination, a source of direct-current potential, a first electric discharge device of the high-vacuum type, a second electric discharge device of the arc like type, a third electric discharge device of the arc-like type, said three devices beingconnected in series with each other and said source, first control means for said first device normally arranged to permit it to conduct current, second control means for said second device normally arranged to permit it to conduct current, third control means for said third device including biasing means normally tending to maintain it non-conductive, means for overcoming said biasing means to render said third device conductive whereby current is con ducted through said three devices, means associated with said first control means and operable a predetermined time after said third device becomes conductive to render said first device momentarily non-conductive and thereby render said second and third devices non-conductive, and means associated with said second control means for preventing said second device from again becoming conductive for a predetermined time after said first device is rendered non-conductive. I

6. In combination, a source of direct-current potential, at first electric discharge device of the high-vacuum type, a second'electric discharge device of the arc-like typein series with said first device, a first control circuit for said first device normally arranged to ermit it to conduct current, a second control circuit for said second device normally arranged to permit it to conduct current, a pair of capacitors connected to be charged simultaneously at predetermined rates by current flowing from said source through said devices, a third electric discharge device of the arc-like type, conducting means connecting said third device in series with said first and second devices, a third control circuit for said third device including one of said capacitors arranged to render said third device conductive when the charge on said one capacitor attains a preselected magnitude, means associated with said first control circuit and responsive to current flowing through said third device for rendering said first device non-conductive, whereby said second and third devices become non-conductive, the other of said capacitors being connected in said second control circuit to prevent said second device from becoming conductive while the charge on said other capacitor is above a preselected magnitude, and means for discharging said other capacitor at a fixed rate after said first device is means in series with said source, a capacitor connected through rectifying means to said valve means to be charged at a predetermined rate. by current supplied from said source through said valve means, an electric discharge device of the arc-like type connected in series with said valve means but in parallel circuit relation with said capacitor and rectifying means, a control circuit for said device including said capacitor arranged to render said device conductive when the charge on said capacitor attains a predetermined magnitude, means responsive to current flowing through said device to render said valve means non-conductive, a discharge circuit for said capacitor including a second electric discharge device of the arc-like type, second means respon sive to current flowing through said first device for rendering said second device conductive, and means for preventing said valve means from becoming conductive for a predetermined time after it is rendered non-conductive.

9. In combination, a source of. direct-current potential, a first electric discharge device of the high-vacuum type, a econd electric discharge device of the arc-like type in series with said first device and said source, a first control circuit for said first device normally arranged to permit it to conduct current, a second control circuit for said second device normally arranged to permit it to conduct current, a capacitor connected in a series circuit with rectifying means and said first and second devices to be charged at a predetermined rate by current flowing from said source through said devices, a third electric discharge device of the arc-like type connected in series with said first and second devices but in parallel circuit relation with said capacitor and rectifying means, a control circuit for said third device including said capacitor arranged to render said third device conductive when the charge on said capacitor attains a predetermined magnitude, means responsive to current flowing through said third device to render said first device momentarily non-conductive and thereby render said second device non-conductive, second means responsive to current flowing through said third device for dis-charging said capacitor, and means for preventing said second device from becoming conductive for a predetermined time after it is rendered non-conductive.

device including biasing means normally tending to maintain it non-conductive, means for overcoming said biasing means to render said third device conductive whereby current is conducted through said three devices, a capacitor connected in series with said devices to be charged at a pre determined rate by the current flowing therethrough, means associated with said first control means and responsive to a charge of a predetermined magnitude on said capacitor to render said first device momentarily non-conductive whereby said second and third devices are rendered non-conductive, and means associated with said second control means for preventing said second device from becoming conductive for a predetermined time after said first device is rendered non-conductive.

11. For use in supplying current from a first source of periodically pulsating potential to a load, the combination comprising valve means for controlling the flow of current to the load, a second source of direct-current potential, a first electric discharge device of the high-vacuum type, a second electriddischarge device of the arc-like type, a third electric discharge device of the arc-like type, said three devices being connected in series with each other and said second source, a first control circuit for said first device normally arranged to permit it to conduct current, a second control circuit for said second device normally arranged to permit it to conduct current, a third control circuit for said third device including biasing potential means normally maintaining it non-conductive, means for impressing a potential impulse in said third control circuit at a preselected instant in each period of said first source which is efiective to overcome said biasing potential and render said third device conductive whereby current is conducted through all three devices, means associated with said first control circuit and operable a predetermined time after said third device becomes conductive to render said first device momentarily non-conductive and thereby render said second and third devices non-conductive, means associated with said second control circuit for prevent- 

